Update: Mooreoceras is no longer considered a valid genus. Kröger and Mapes (2005) compared more than 1,000 specimens and found that its type species, M. normale, cannot be separated from Pseudorthoceras knoxense. Specimens I once called Mooreoceras are now catalogued as P. knoxense. More on the Pseudorthoceras page.
Going by the fossil example shown on the Pennsylvanian Atlas of Ancient Life, I am calling this find a Pseudorthoceras. The rock was split into two pieces, and the photo is of them joined back up. The white markings are from an air scribe.

Pseudorthoceras belongs to the class Cephalopoda. Mooreoceras can also be found in the local rocks and could also be what this particular specimen is.

Pseudorthoceras

